Thursday, August 27, 2009
PS-- homework ;)
1) a story about a time that a work of art (preferably performance, since that's our focus, but it can really be anything) added something to your life beyond aesthetic or intellectual pleasure, when you found a work of art capable of changing you or changing something to make the world a better place...
2) a story about one of these:
a) a time that you felt your (performance/artistic) work "made a difference" somehow in the world, had meaning and value beyond your personal satisfaction...
or
b) a time that you felt your (performance/artistic) work didn't make a difference, or was useless to the rest of the world, or that you questioned the relevance or value of what you were doing/making...
Session #1
I am interested in how people who are socially conscious and have the desire to make the world a better place can manifest those concerns through artistic practice. For me these are very personal and timely questions, about why I do what I do, and how to do it as I go forward in life. In the past couple of years I have been more and more interested and engaged in doing work “in the community”. Whatever that means. Working with “marginalized populations”. Again, we know what it means, but what does it mean? Is making performance/art the best way I can contribute to the world? Is it the most satisfying way? Does it serve a need in society? These are some of my personal questions, and I have come up with some more for us to ponder as a group. Feel free to write notes or jot down any thoughts on these questions, or even to respond in comments on the blog before we go into our first session. Sorry if i repeat myself below--i didn't really do any editing.
-Why perform or make performance work? Is the act important for the performer or is it about the experience of the audience that is primary motivation? Obviously it is both, and obviously neither category can exist without the other, but taking that as a given, still the question remains for me: Am I doing it for my own sake or for others’?
- What does “community” mean to you? What communitie/s do you belong to? Do you think about any particular community, or your affiliations to them, when creating or performing work?
- In journalism exists the concept of the “general reader” (although supposedly this is going the way of the dinosaur with the advent of the internet, etc). Do we believe in a kind of “general audience” for dance or performance? Is this desirable? Is this a useful concept? How much do we consider the audience when making work?
- Does making dance/performance make a difference in the “community” (which one?) or in the world? Why? Do you want it to? Should it?
- What is the difference between creating “professional” work and “community” work? (I sometimes think of this question as “Rhodessa vs. Bill T.”)
- When working in community settings (ie, non-professional), what are the benefits of teaching a class vs. building a performance together? Why is it useful for non-professional performers to perform? For them, for the audience, for the facilitators of such work? What do people need to have a satisfying experience (on both sides of the stage)
-How is “community theater” different than “theater in the community”? Does “community theater” merely repeat the traditional modes and forms of theater (established plays, musicals) but with less technical skill? And conversely, is “theater in the community” a format that places less emphasis on virtuosity or technical skills? Do we have different criteria for “talent” or skill level or how we judge a performance based on our knowledge of the participants’ training or experience level? Do we need to create new forms, or have we created new forms, of creative process that democratize the process of making and performing work? Are these concerns relevant to the field of professional performers as well, or implement-able?
- Is it possible to live out one’s democratic or political ideals in the process or product of performance work? Or does the emphasis on that kill the art side of things? Is the personal really political? Can the political really be art?
- What are lessons learned or values/principles inherent to your artistic practice that impact the rest of your life? Do you want to share these with others? Do you think performance work can do that? Or teaching? Or facilitating other people’s creative process in some other way?
- For those that teach: What is it that you want to transmit—what lies beneath or behind the content of your teaching?
And this question can also pertain to performance: What are you trying to transmit or share? Content, form, emotion, your own human experience, beauty, truth …. (those last two are doozies—I’m interested in these questions on a philosophical level, but also want to be as concrete and specific as possible when talking about them. ie—what do I really mean when I say beauty or truth?)
- Do I want people to watch me having an experience, or do I want to facilitate other people having that experience? Do I want to dance for people or to get them to dance? If I derive so much meaning and value from the experience of being in my body and moving it around, or from solving problems in time and space with “theatrical” tools, how can I multiply or amplify that into something that’s beneficial for more people than just myself?
Saturday, August 1, 2009
Really Real Performance
I have developed an aversion to fakeness. Okay, I still wear synthetic fabrics and have even been known to eat tempeh “bacon”. But in the realm of dance performance, when what is happening seems fake, I find myself getting frustrated and even upset. I find myself wondering “what for”?
I’d like to see what we can discover about what it is about fakeness or artificiality that can undermine the effectiveness of performance art. More importantly, what is real in a performance context and how do we create something real? Is performance an inherently artificial act? What is the interplay between real and artificial in performance art?
What is artificial? Some possibilities
- performers who seem to go through the motions without intention
- unquestioned theatrical clichés
- dance technique - is there a point where artistry and skill tip over somehow into cunning and trickery and deception?
- overdramatic acting
- Lots of other stuff
Art >> Artifice >> Artificial
Apparently one of the earlier meanings of artifice was simply: the product of art, or of skillful art. “But whenever you emphasize human skill in doing something, you stretch into the realms of finesse or cleverness, and this is not far from the domain of trickery or ruse.” Perhaps this is what makes the artificiality of performance seductive and interesting. I love seeing well-crafted work, and technical proficiency and virtuosity, but I have a longing for something real, substantial.
What is real? Some possibilities that are or seem real
performers having real experiences as humans while they are performing
Why this is important, and is it apparent to the audience witnessing the performance?
Unplanned moments
When the CD starts skipping and the music goes out, suddenly we are all snapped out of the comfort of knowing basically what is going to happen, and both performers and audience are discovering the moment in the moment. We catch a glimpse of the person and not just the seasoned performer. This makes me wonder whether the effect of unplanned moments can be built into a piece, or whether a space could be opened to make them more likely. Can the unplanned be planned?
Pedestrian and task based movement
When a person eats an orange on the stage, we are seeing a real person eat a real orange. Is this interesting? Pedestrian movement being transplanted onto a stage has been happening for almost 50 years. Is it still valid? Is it more interesting when something familiar and pedestrian happens in the context of the artificial and aesthetic, so it may be that it is the friction between what is real and what is artificial or contrived that is compelling.
Genuine interactions between people
This seems particularly compelling in a setting where interaction is often formulaic. How do we create the opportunity for genuine interactions between performing people, and between the performing people and the audience people, and between audience people and other audience people?
Really Artificial
What if you are real about being artificial? If you perform theatrically, but do the self-aware post-modern thing and acknowledge the performative and theatrical nature of what you are doing and deconstruct it, is this more real? Is this too self-referential to be meaningful? Or does it stimulate interesting and useful questions?
Does artifice actually make things seem real? Is the appearance to be real just as good as being real?
What is this stuff for, anyway?
“Real” life is going on all the time, so do we look to performances to provide a break from that reality? To reflect reality? To simply provide another experience?
The intersection of Real and Artificial
I suspect it is a combination of real and artificial that makes for an interesting and thought provoking performance. Unshaped reality may be boring (unless approached with Cage-ian attention). But performance made up entirely of spectacle or theatrical conventions feels empty. Is it that they are both necessary, each drawing attention to the other so we can question them? If so, how do we do this effectively?