Monday, November 9, 2009

Community Research Day 2.0

Open Process Day #2

Saturday November 7, 2009 at Intersection

There are slips of paper on each seat with a question:

What aspects of your personal history, background or upbringing do you feel are present or relevant in how you experience your art?

Do you see your status in society having an effect on your participation in the performance/art world?

How has your upbringing affected your choice to be an artist/participate in art?

I. Intro: We’ll introduce the topic, and a little about why it’s interesting, and what our particular focus is, our desire to ground the discussion around art and art-making rather than identity politics, etc.

Through talking about the ego and self identity, we started talking about personal history and how that affects our art making and goes into the art world.

II. Introduce/discuss community agreements:

1. Respect for different opinions in the room.

2. Be mindful and careful about naming names when talking about work. Respect for each other and respect for the community.

3. Step up, step back. Make sure everyone’s voice gets heard that wants to be heard.

4. Question your assumptions about what people are saying, also about where they’re coming from.

III. Ice breaker: Human bingo game, going around the room and trying to find people to fill in our bingo sheet. Ex: someone who has a cat…

Having assumptions about people based on their appearance, who I think is in this room. I don’t think that anyone who would come to this would have a kid, but there are people here. What someone looks like doesn’t mean that’s who they are.

The notion of owning v. having. Capitalistic sense of owning and community based notion of owning. I rent an apartment from someone I don’t even like, but I own the space in a lot of ways, it’s my home.

IV. Brainstorm/Mindmap: Butcher paper on the wall. Brainstorm together around “class and privilege in the art world” which will be written in the center. We’ll invite all kinds of responses to this, totally open free association brainstorm.

What’s written on the diagram, split into categories:

1. What is success? Happiness, valuing art making as a spiritual practice, beingness v. doingness, does success affect the quality of one’s art making, income praise, legitimate art, high art, how do we define success in the dance world, can choreography be a hobby, who do I know, economics

2. Resources and accessibility: child of musicians, suburban ballet class, access to finance, what resources are required for art making: time, space, money, bodies.

3. Upbringing: what your parents did, what your friends do, how that influences what you do and why you are in the artist world, knowing how to live simple and use my resources

V. Small group discussion:

Report back:

1. Success:

Conversation stirred a lot, and it’s flying all over the place, Ugh, feel like now I’m doomed.

The idea of what makes a successful art work and successful artist, those need to be in line for your trajectory. As the garden goes so goes the gardener. The idea of the successful artist, if that differs from your idea of successful art. If that’s different when things like monetary issues and pressure can veer your art in that way. Example: One way is to look out into the audience, if it’s full, that’s successful v. asking yourself, did I achieve what I went for as an artist, personally, did I address the goals that I wanted to address in this performance. Successful artists have both successful and unsuccessful pieces, but overall the trajectory, is one that they themselves are feel successful for the art, or they are successful in a national/economic/fame sense.

Product and how one produces work are part in parcel of the piece. If you are a shitty director then that piece will be shitty? More simply economic success, what did the reviewer think.

Question: Did the question of failure come up? We never used the word failure. The language is so mushy, unless it gets really specific. Sometimes behind the scenes sometimes I don’t feel successful as the only one, but others think it’s successful.

2. Resources and access:

My take is that a lot of productive artists, spend a lot of time thinking about their resources, strategizing, shaking hands, being seen in the right places, writing grants, schmoozing with funders. That maybe an observation, but I think that a lot of artists want to be making work, not thinking of these things. Talked about going back to school is a way of building relationships, getting started yet that’s a very specific trajectory. One pro is not having all the debt. Not all artist have an MFA either.

Do you take a survival job that has nothing to do with your art and are miserable doing it, or do you take a related job, where you are an administrator and get too tied up. What happens when you need to take time out to make personal needs, how do you stock up sources of inspiration. Once you do start going, you have momentum, but you is there anything like taking a break? What’s going to happen to your art and your relationships. What is best for the art doesn’t seem like it’s always best for the artist, those things don’t always line up. Very simply it comes down to time and space. What are the resources you need to make art. What it comes down to is that.

3. Upbringing:

We all mentioned our parents at some point. Our accessibility, and where we come from. How we create and what our process directly reflected from where we come from, people who come from artistic families, backgrounds, have a certain stigma going on place we are going. Those who come from a non artistic upbringing have a different thing going on. All had a really tender experience of wanting to have their parents come see their work. Some people think that their parents would understand it, some not. No one left that out that they wanted. There was talk of privilege that we can do this because parents support the artist financially. There is this idea of parents supporting the artist, my parents didn’t support that but they weren’t against it. I wish we had more time for this. Didn’t get to other things, excavating racism within the self, what that means.

VI. Creating diagram/structure/maps of the art/performance/dance world. Same small groups. 20 minutes. Walked around and took tour of the each groups maps.

VII. Question score: 10 mins of just questions (skipped)

VIII. Open discussion for the rest of the time.

Talking about the maps:

Want to know about the whale.

Difference between the creative side of art and business side of art.

Ancestors in more than one.

Dancers at the head of the table because usually dancers are begging directors for parts, but really if it weren’t for them there wouldn’t even have any dance. We need the numbers to make things happen. Concept came from the thought that we all learned to perform at the dinner table, or didn’t perform at the dinner table. The table is the institutional art field. This is us there is a feeling of contempt from the folks off in the corner at Mcdonald’s. Similarly there’s the expensive art world. There are hierarchies on so many levels. No matter what lens you look though there are so many assumptions. So much of that is true. There is an element of preciousness that makes me think, who cares? There is envy in that wanting access to money, and attention. The idea of having feeling an artistic community, people who have more access to funding and resources, feelings arise. Imagining where we put each other on here, imagining out selves in different locations, whether it’s in bigger prosceniums in little town, or small tiny places in a big city. That was the intention behind the eyes. You couldn’t ever see anyone when you are a performer in a big space, you’re dancing to the balcony, but when you’re here in tiny spaces in SF, you can see every single pair of eyes in the audience. It is an interesting thing to go from having dancer face to being in this intimate space. Imagining connections between the people who want to make the work and who they want to show it to.

Relational aesthetics, the next great subject for artists are social relations. Artists who reconstitute McDonald’s and what is actually on display is the social relations. They have rebuilt cafes in museums and what is on display is the social interactions between the performers.

What I’m not seeing here is the relationship between artists. I’m thinking that most people want more money and might be envious of those people with money, but I’m happy without that. There is reverse envy about being an artist. People might grill us about what artists actually do, and then they are really actually wishing that they had the same kind of freedom. They are envious.

I have a piece on here about collaborating with people from BART stations after not getting people from craigslist. I have three collaborators that I’ve asked in BART stations, musicians.

IX. This topic is so big, I could talk another day of this topic. Just have conversation on those topics.

I like the forced intersection of these topics. But it’s all related and how our society structured, how we were brought up in those structures how were are trying to come up with things through all this and through our personal histories. Talk about where they are coming from, how they’re art is informed by that.

This is all part of an experimental process, for us and for everyone here. It is a unique way to enter into a discussion, just as much as for those who came to join. Create a structure and invite people to be part of our experiment.

Tapping into personal narrative has brought up more. Want to bubble this stuff up, turning over in the loam and bring things up.

Rollover: Who is a dancer? Who gets to call themselves a dancer? If you don't call yourself a dancer, why not?

No comments:

Post a Comment