MMW Session 3.0
Peter: Ego and “The Artiste”
October 23, 2009 at Intersection
I. Intro
As I accumulate my experience, how does that affect what I create? What holds me back and what challenges me? Sometimes I feel like I hit a wall, I would like to brainstorm what you all do in that situation. This isn’t judgment, but just questions, to help further what you do.
II. Discussions of questions:
A. Who do you think you are, as an artist?
Peter: I am an imaginative artist, who deals with the realm of reality. I put personal and social narratives together. I can be opinionated, can be reactive.
Erika: Inspired by real life things, interactions between people, relationships, things that are confusing to me. I’m more of a director, that’s where I feel comfortable, musicals, specific choreographic assignments, like being campy.
Jessica: I am an adult child. Have an artist statement, but it’s a living changing document.
Jen: This brought up a lot of fear and negative emotions. I’m not sure that I identify or allowed to call myself an artist. I often feel like a dilettante, because I do lots of things and I’m passionate about a lot of things. I think I have to be recognized and good at being an artist to claim that. On the bright side I feel like I try to approach my life, my finances, my relationships, by being creative. I like the juiciness of life, and the creativity, which I think makes me an artist. I haven’t applied myself in any one field to really be super accomplished as an artist.
Jorge: Full of questions, angst, contradictions, still with a sense of direction. I’m not sure where it’s going but there is a sense of direction. Privilege, resistance and ambition. This to me is who are you, and then, pause, as an artist. Life art balance, the things that limit me in my art limit me in my life. Privilege, I’m not self sustainable, parents pay for health insurance, don’t have 401K, not saving up, so I don’t have any back up, basically I’m supported. Resistance, reason to do art, is because I have a sense of resistance. There is something that needs to be said. Ambitious, because I feel I have a lot of ambition, and I’m reconciling that with being a good artist and good person, trying to keep myself active. I want to be able to be creative in all parts of my life. Sometimes I think if I make a piece I’m an artist, but art can be made in any medium.
Erin: I feel like if I’m not actively making something I don’t quite feel like an artist. Who I am as an artist is filled with doubt. When I do make work, it’s usually about relationships, and it’s modest in the way that it’s familiar and small bits of reality. That tends to be what I do. I’ve been approached about collaboration, and I’m riding on my creative past, which now I will talk with visual artist and it seems I’m now the dance expert. Even though I feel like I have low artist self esteem but with these people I am a choreographer, and can move people around a space, I have experience in that. But this is separate from being an artist, who has the ideas and comes up with new things; to me a choreographer is a craftsperson.
Kegan: Sculptor and storyteller. Also an element of scientist and egotistical performer. Member of and someone in search of community.
Jesse: I had a problem answering this without jargon, post modern, etc. I tend to make dances that the audience wants to see and are fun to perform. Putting that on stage sometimes feels very self indulgent. But I’m opening up without forcing it.
Mary Ann: Question mark. It’s always evolving.
Peter: When I read the question back to myself, I wanted to scream, “I don’t know!” My reaction to that was to make up stuff. Or take things that I know that I’ve done and I can asses. Like because of this work I’ve made this is part of who I am. Part of saying I don’t know, is what allows me to create and keep going. I had lots of fear that came up.
Kegan: I’m really interested in people seeing me in the space, and not seeing a performer, detached from all the different parts of me. I’m not compelled by the ballet body that can be swapped out by someone else. When I’m sharing in a room with others that they are seeing me and I’m seeing them.
Jen: I see that as anti-egotistical. Generosity of spirit, that would allow people see you, making someone see what you, but only what you want them to see, like the ballerina who you see the shapes and form.
Jessica: Does anyone know the definition of the ego. Saying egotistical, I’d like to know what that means to you, can mean so many things.
Peter: What do you think ego is? I go back and forth between thinking the ego is self-identity, and sometimes when it’s useful to an argument, the ego is not necessarily good and it’s shameful. Self-identity for me can mean who I truly am. I can’t usually find words for, it’s spirit. I usually identify that bounced back through other people.
Jessica: When a toddler develops a relationship between an outer-world and inner-world. Difference between myself and you. I remember being a kid and thinking I am me, and that was astounding to me. The word ego usually means self centered, elevating oneself. I saw self-identity as more what group I might identify with. With whom do I identify? You astrological sun sign, how do I want to present myself to the world. Ego has many definitions.
Jorge: There is an action somehow in self identity. How do I identify my self, it’s a social activity almost. Ego starts from the raw inside, then goes outward into the social.
Jen: Self identity is more about the roles that I play, I am a dancer, or a daughter, more like a role that fits into a social fabric. I am me, ego, that is some kind of separateness. Egoism is hard for me in my own spirituality.
Erin: To separate yourself, protect yourself, the ego is false, in Buddhist thought reality is that you have this self but that everything is everything. So it’s contradictory , ego as contradicting the self, rather than self identify, the self is what’s left when you take all these social constructs away, like being a dancer or daughter, but self identity is who you are choosing to be in any given moment.
Jen: The fact that we are separate makes it so that we can create really interesting art. It doesn’t deny that there is a sensual world and tactile things, but at the same time you realize they are not actually here, not actually real.
Mary Ann: A lot is attached to ego. It almost stands alone outside of us, as its meaning, as it’s been understood throughout history. My definition of ego is just the self, but I think about what I project on ego, all the art related to it, all the ways people talk about ego, the word egotistical, but that’s not the basic definition. How am I informed of this word through the world that seems larger than me.
Jorge: It exists, starting from the raw us, and interacting like this. It’s an archetype, it’s a shell, ego is on the outside, it’s a social construction. Ego is construction of these things, we all want to fully realize who we are without destroying others, but there is fear in that because it’s exposed and can be shot down.
Erin: When we talk about ego it’s too big or too fragile, so we have to protect it.
Maryann: So charged compared to the word I or self. It’s like the paparazzi is following you.
Erika: I’m finding feelings but not words to talk about them. #5: For me to be in touch with my own voices in my own head. For me as a creator, I have a very private relationship with what’s in my head, there are two or more things going on, two dialogues at the same time. In order to create consistently I have to block out a lot, I have to bock things out because it might be devastating or just overwhelming. I have to stay sane and safe, and have to put up walls. In relation to my own work and own processes. There is a real stubbornness in moving forward, I’m so sensitive, if I allow it all to come in I can’t see anymore. The way I can see most clearly then I have to almost say fuck you, not because I’m mad, but to create space around me. That fuck you feels like it’s driven by my egotistical side, but without that I get overwhelmed to not work. I know that living in this California world, growing up with Buddhist parents, an environment that values a selflessness, of generosity of spirit, the best egoless listener, I feel there is a contradiction between being an empathetic person versus having an artistic force.
Jessica: Tools of coating yourself in a layer, when you need to not be so porous. You’re talking about real tools. You are making art for the world, but in order to make that process you are making a safe container, and not get caught up in what else is going on. You are staying focused on what you want to focus on.
Erika: About being seen, the more personal it is the more universal: that idea and how that relates to all these questions. When do you let down your protection?
Jen: The big ‘S’ self, contains the little ‘s’ self, my aspiration is to exist an hold the two levels simultaneously. In terms of shutting out other perspectives, in interpersonal relationship, because you see yourself as the same as someone else you don’t lose your power of discernment, and you can be receptive and discrete at the same time. I think of bamboo being able to bend but not break, it doesn’t change your form or what you can return to.
Erin: as an artist you need to be receptive, it’s not all coming out of you all the time. You have to see the world in order to give to it.
Jorge: When you start making something, you call out to the universe, you ask the question and let a lot in, but then you have to start cutting things out and crafting what you are actually creating.
Jen: It’s like being able to change your aperture, sometimes you need to keep it big, and sometimes small, but that process is not linear, it can depend on the process and project.
Mary Ann: Something I struggle with: because we live in such a capitalist driven society, the culture doesn’t hold the artist as sacred. There is always this struggle in what we do because we aren’t seen as necessary. We don’t have a culture that’s based in any spiritual foundation where the artist has a role. We have to create that. Always trying to create that as myself doesn’t make sense to me. I feel like I’m always fighting against selling myself, or this doesn’t feel like the way it’s supposed to be. To me this question feels like a struggle, because it doesn’t feel like our culture supports us. Traditional art forms are much more supportive, there is a place for it.
Erin: Specialized artist roles are actually kind of a modern thing. But there isn’t a separation between roles in traditional culture. We wouldn’t be having this conversation if we were paid even $50,000 per year, even 20,000. If you are a CEO of dance, wouldn’t be here.
Erin: I question if it is a special thing to be an artist. If it’s elevated, if we are special. Maybe it should be, I go back and forth. There are emerging artists who feel like they should be entitled and we should be supported, but art clearly makes peoples’ lives better. But what I see artists that are selfish and think I should be supported so I can do my thing. I want to make work because I want to make it and want people to see it.
Jessica: I get uncomfortable with the using of the word elevation. Anyone who in their field thinks they are elevated is not ok to me.
Erin: Craftsperson is more grounded. What is an artist’s responsibility, and is it greater than someone doing something else?
Kegan: The sense of the specialized artist, saying this is going to be my practice, way of sustaining, not just part of my life. It seems to be like cooking, when it became something that not just everyone did. We all have to eat, but some people took it further. It came out of French culture and criticism, people started to acknowledge the difference and quality in taste of food and how it’s prepared. We all cook and we all have to eat, everyone has to engage in creative practice in our lives.
Erin: That brings in the quality and the good. Do you get to say you are an artist if you aren’t good at it? It’s the external, you say I’m a professional dancers because someone paid me for it.
Kegan: What do I expect of myself to say I’m an artist. I constantly try to reference other things, successful chefs, what do they have to do to support themselves.
Jorge: In a western context, someone from African dance and drum ensemble, it’s hard for her to call herself an artist, because it’s just part of her life and what she does. In western context, being an artist is specialized thing, there is not a unifying belief system, or religion to contextualize. It’s very secular society. This is our relationship to the outside world. What is our value as artists? When you go to the theater people want to have a transcended experience, they want to be changed. They want the same as when you go to church. As artists that’s what we offer. We also have a sense of responsibility. No matter what job you have, we are all connected to the same responsibility, it’s a shared thing. With art it’s tough to know there is a responsibility to put something out there, if my contribution to society is art there is so much responsibility to produce good art. We have this pressure because we are at an elevated status. But maybe part of being an artist is to teach others that we all have the responsibility to create.
Jen: I’m split though because in different social/economic positions art has such a different place. Some elevated, some devalued. What gets upsetting is that because an artist has a facility in expressing feelings that they then feel more deeply. Artists have an ability to show people tools and help people access. People think that if you don’t get
Erin: If you work in a factory making cogs, success is defined, to make a good cog you know what to do, but making a good piece of art you don’t know what to do. It also comes down to purpose, supply and demand, going to put it in a car.
Jessica: Who we are as a person, who we are in our jobs. Artist is still a person and the cog manufacturer is still a person. The way to show ego is that I can say because I’m an artist I’m a better person, which I find horribly problematic.
Peter: What happens when someone or something challenges you? What happens to your identity? Like if someone says he didn’t get your work. Sometimes I’ll either shut down, or push harder in one specific way. I get angry because I’m insecure. It comes down to self doubt. Sometimes I blow it off, but that’s usually a front and then I go home and shatter privately. I think, is what I’m doing worth anything? My ego is either beating the shit out of me or it’s elevating me. Either you’re worthless or you’re great. When my ego is hurt I don’t think clearly at all.
Mary Ann: It totally changes if I’m working for someone else. Then I feel worse than if I’m doing my own work. With myself there is more fluidity and more breath, but if I’m working for someone else I feel more responsibility to that person, it’s a totally different context, a totally different dynamic.
Erin: When you work for someone else, you don’t have as many tools to make it right, there is a smaller window of what you need to accomplish.
Jen: What am I in terms of being a dancer, working for others, creator, artist? Which of these is primary, which do I identify with more. Which is more useful to me, better at? For performance art, it seems like it’s different than other forms, like writers.
Jessica: When someone challenges you, I think it‘s important to think about the source. I’m not sure how to do that. I think that’s when somatic are helpful. If you’re shutting down what’s happening, and what is that doing? Awareness of yourself and your body: Are you feeling like you want to pull back, pull forward, get yourself grounded. Is this person just talking through their style? It’s important to separate opinion from fact. Just naming their intention can be helpful. You can replace that with interpersonal relationships too, look at these things across the board.
Peter: Who is reacting to these challenges that come up for me. Is it my ego that is reacting to it? It’s like a succession, it’s my ego, then it gets to my identity, then it drips down into my self. That’s where the real doubt comes.
Mary Ann: What is your practice? How do you get past all that to get to your work?
Peter: It’s a constant ebb and flow and going through hell then coming out and having an epiphany. Sometimes people’s reactions help me see what can happen during my process, that people can get something out of it.
Erin: I think accepting challenges is part of being a good artist. Apply something rational to it, decide if you think it’s valid. As you create the next thing, you decide if you want to implement the change and challenge or not. The most useful way to react to a challenge is to look at it and think, how am I going to use this? How am I responding, what’s going on, and to then know if you want to dismiss it and incorporate it. We don’t want to be so fragile to not accept.
Mary Ann: I think it‘s interesting to see that in a piece. But to see that struggle, and that interaction.
Erika: We are all trying to make work that is vulnerable and honest. We think it’s real, we put things out there and people like it, don’t like it, don’t care. We put intimate things out there, and we must be crazy if we keep doing this again and again.
Kegan: I’m trying to match how I get praise to how I get criticism. We are skilled at blowing off praise, and great at accepting criticism. I think looking at the source from the source of both praise and criticism. I am extra good at blowing off praise from someone who I don’t agree with or think too highly of.
Peter: Quote I heard once: All criticism is autobiographical. Dig yourself.
Jen: One of the leaders of an at risk youth yoga class, so I have to think: Can you in every instance of teaching not be attached to the final end victory, but rather the small victories. You can’t know what is happening inside of someone. It’s different teaching than making art. But sometimes you have a really clear sense of what you want to give someone, and you hold that really strongly within yourself, but can you totally detach yourself from that. It’s a huge challenge.
Jorge: You are one person and say one thing, but it’s interpreted 50 different ways. Asked someone once about his ego, if he thinks about being famous in a greater sense and getting to be well known. He said he’s is not asking to be successful or famous, he is getting reviews and he does look for them. Sometimes it creeps up, a hope that each work will make him famous. Then he catches that and tries to ground himself in anarchist places.
Peter: That quote, for me, means that when someone is criticizing you it is coming from themselves, so we all need to watch what we say.
Kegan: I think we should just acknowledge our perception of someone else’s ego, when Jorge brought that up. There was a very clear and interesting visceral response.
Jesse: Everyone knew what you were talking about. I also feel respect for him, he can hold himself in that egotistical way, but within himself he is so clear in what he’s doing. I feel like I don’t have enough confidence to be like that, I’m envious. His vision is so clear, but to talk about your work for 30 minutes straight, I wish I had more state of mind like that to manifest what I saw.
Mary Ann: I’m always trying to figure out how to do my art. As I get older and mellow out, I see that when I’m teaching or doing whatever I do, it’s all informing what else I’m doing. It’s all there to be in a place to show my work, be the artist that I want to be. I admire people like that who can be like that and push that role and have that kind of support or get there. Being an artist in this culture, that’s the struggle, it’s real.
Erin: I think that some people it’s because of the ego he is successful, not in spite of it. You have to believe that you have something to say that matters to someone other than you. Talking about the work, he was talking about the piece. If you believe in what you are creating. If you ask me what I am as an artist, I have nothing to say. Criticism is autobiographical, is that the only criticism that has meaning?
Jorge: When you are surrounded by a status and voices. When you put something out, there is a lot more feedback and voice. I am more interested in that and what that’s like. When you are talking about a work or art, it’s us, it’s a birth. That’s helpful to be confident about something, but it’s easier to be like that after the work is done and people liked it.
Kegan: Really responded to Jesse: our role and perception in helping people get to this transcendent place. Are we helping others build and manifest their ego? Modeling for people? Challenge as an artist: when I responded I wasn’t thinking criticism, but when I’m in the midst of a performance, if I feel challenged by the audience. When I feel the audience isn’t coming along with me, or is in competition with me, or the work is not being received in the way that I want it to be received (been doing lots of improvisation recently) then I will do a trick, or feat of strength. Sometimes it works, sometimes not, more often not. What’s been shifting is by doing that I’m taken out of the original intention of the work. Now I see that’s a cue for me to go back to the original intentions.
Jen: Also the automatic desire to be famous, but trying to stay grounded.
Kegan: I think if the audience isn’t getting it, it’s because I think they don’t like the postmodern craziness that’s going, but then I try to show them that I am a skilled craftsman.
B. Tools for getting over yourself (self – identity) as an artist?
Peter: Like talking about Erika’s “Fuck you world!” being receptive and open minded, compassionate to myself. Not to attach to any outcome, if I build it they will come, or not, which is fine too. Have confidence. As I’m struggling to keep it together on the outside, have confidence. Sometimes my process is to chip away at something, but keep doing that until someone challenges you, that you’ll overcompensate, for whatever feeling is coming up for you. When you’re not doing that, what sort of tools you use, maybe to not take yourself to seriously.
Erika: I seek out uncomfortable collaborations, types of situations that feel unnatural and just put yourself into that. Apply for grants that you know you won’t get, so you feel you are part of a larger pool, just to feel that. Seek mentors who are like smarter and better, and allow yourself to bow to them and believe that they are smarter and better. We get so critical, but allow yourself to be groveling to someone else. Ask your grandparents what they think of your work. Speaking of mentors: “Structurables.” I use to help as a way to gage my success, it’s a tool to see whether you have engaged with your goals or not. With every piece, I’m going to make structural goals, maybe they are: two people, unrecorded music, text generated by just me. So that structure holds your aims and at the end of the project you see if you came through with those goals. So your success is dependent on how you stuck to you or goals, you’re not just making something great or impressive.
Jen: Revisiting works of art that you love, could be stuff you make, but I was thinking more about others work. For me it’s “Revelations.” Having humility in the face of a mentor and something to aspire to. Going to classes, training, doing something that’s not about a product but that is building skills. Regular person activities with non artists. Watching tv with my brother. Yoga or meditation or spiritual practice, so that I am not just me, everyone is one, you must practice this. Quote: I need hobbies at which I am a rank beginner to keep me honest. Picking up the accordion, drawing, not with the aim to become great at it, but keep me honest.
Erin: Very much enjoyed doing other things that have no pressure, and would like to apply that to my profession as an artist. What I usually need to get over is doubt. Getting other people into the room, when it’s just me, when I’m thinking and creating, I self doubt. Having someone else’s idea, that may not seem like a good idea, I can get dismissive to others, but if you can try something else. This might be at an earlier point than the “fuck you world.”
Jorge: To get over myself, is easier said than done. Just do something, get working. Once you’re working, then you are in and doing it. With my religious views, and clairvoyance of others, we are all matter, we are on a physical place, everything’s physical, but we are infused with life. Cultivating a support group, developing community, talks with others, got stage manager, outside eyes, and others. You are not alone, support helps. So that you can ride the energy that you create with others when your energy is down, don’t feel like doing it, or don’t know what to do.
Jessica: Look at a map of the world. Whatever that means, so many stories happening, not to belittle my story, but it’s not the only story. Be prepared so that you can focus on the work. The times I’ve been scared of failure, are those that I am not prepared. Know your patterns to recognize them and make conscious choices. I have been a serial creator, one project to the other, sometimes they overlap. I just do it because that’s where I came from that’s how I learned to make work, I wasn’t making conscious choices of how to make. Take breaks, do something else. Go to the movies. So that there is space to reflect or not reflect. Clarify how you will or won’t self identify in the work. In this piece am I communicating who I am, is it neutral ballet bodies, is it caricature. Clarifying what everyone’s role is, who it’s about.
Erika: I learned that having a support group outside of the process, my dear friends and husband was in the process. Just need to cry and rant for some time. I just need to know that there are people on the outside that are not part of it at all. Just have people, just knowing that they are there, ready for my phone call and take it, felt so good just knowing that at all times.
Jen: How to engage, performance is so often a social endeavor. You are the creator and people are the paint and your canvas. It’s so complicated and specific to this art form. You have to think a lot more about how you are going to use these people, because they are people. I can see where in the past that hasn’t been clear enough. There can be a mismatch.
Kegan: How I get over my own doubts, by looking at the outside processes that I don’t have control over, like now what’s on my mind is economics. That’s just not in my control, so how can I deal with that and acknowledge that. Identifying those outside influences, sometimes I think I have so much control over my work that it’s all my work but there are so many things outside of myself that are influences that I can’t help. Being able to identify these things helps me.
Mary Ann: What it comes down to for me is class, to even have this conversation. In a developing country how are artists doing this, how are they making work. I work with youth who are very disenfranchised. How can I offer something different from an expectation other than ourselves. In our culture class determines whether or not a person will be an artist or not. I come from working class people, it wasn’t part of the scenario of what they were dong, I’m looking at those limitations. Looking at myself, my work has to have meaning and it’s important to tap into social justice issues, I can’t do something that’s not political. Otherwise it doesn’t do anything for me. We have this privilege to assert this identity and otherwise I feel it’s sort of a waste.
Kegan: In privilege, seeing my mom as an artist, even though she had other jobs that weren’t related to the arts, could still be artistic. But now that she doesn’t have outside financial burdens, kids around, she can be an artist.
Jen: So fascinating about class that it’s not just economics. What you can see around you is so specific. You can’t see what else might be accessible, not having the thought or possibility in your mind, that is part of impoverishment too. Even if you have money and space and time you can still have that cut off.
Peter: Talking to someone who is a singer but a teacher by day, says I admire you for being an artist, says I want to be that too. I believe that class plays a role, but class is also how you class yourself. If you say I couldn’t possibly be an artist because I come from…whatever. It’s based on who people think they are. I feel privileged that I at least have the choice. I am recognized as an artist event though I don’t always feel like I am.
C. Fears: List a few things that you are afraid of as a performer/artist.
Peter: Being naked onstage. Did it once, but didn’t like it, still afraid of it. Failure as an artist, people not remembering me. Forgetting whole parts of the material. People will see that I’m fake.
Kegan: Being uninteresting, un-engaging, not knowing why I’m doing something, using technique in place of something else, being sexual as an adult, being overtly political in clichéd way, talking improvisationally, feeling silly.
Jen: Feel like I’m in work I don’t believe in, or not invested in. I always want to be authentic. Acting speaking, speaking like a normal person, composing music, solo work, singing in head voice. I also realize things are what I want to do, which is what makes them scary.
Erin: Writing, speaking my own words delivered on stage, making work that’s unaware, or cliché or bad. Self indulgence.
Jorge: Not fully developing something, so that it lacks integrity of fullness, sucking in comparison to others, not knowing what I’m doing. Saying something when I feel stutter-y, feeling tripped up. Owning my sexuality, owning sexy. Not trying to be sexy. Self indulgence.
Jessica: As a performer: injury, being misunderstood, handstands, sustained balance positions, forgetting choreography/being underprepared.
Jesse: I’ve sung, been naked at the last minute, forgotten lines, improvised talking, but all these things I’ve done and frightened of. Is it fear of or just things that I don’t like to do? I’m not sure.
Erika: Yelling at people in the audience, being to act-y, being too sincere or precious, being boring, or pompous by assuming people are going to be interested in what I’m saying.
Mary Ann: My parents seeing my work. Not me being in someone else’s piece. I’ve done all the things I’m afraid off. I wish I was more funny, so to be able to go onstage and be that is fearful. Raw improvisation would be scary but is also interesting.
Peter: I decided to end with fears can relate back to who we identify with. These are the things that put a chink in the ego, that cut through what we want to put out. Something that came up more than once is improvisation, and not knowing why I’m doing something
Kegan: I don’t like doing work that I can’t defend. Goes back to receiving praise and criticism, if I can defend something, if there is thought behind it, then I’m able to receive praise and criticism about the work and it’s not about me.
Rollover topics: Finding someone outside of our profession.
The process of art making across fields. How do we make our work, how do we share that, our process.
Virtuosity, training of performers.
Being a good director, while still being the person you want to be.
CR Day planning at 10:30, for the first half hour of Peter’s next session.
To start planning: Would like the last hour of the event to debrief. Commit to sending one email to figure out what we’re going to do.